Unverified Voracity Has List Of Things In It! Comment Count

Brian

A mea culpa. A couple things on the fight song kerfuffle from yesterday. One: apparently there are people who have escaped Taken memery. (They probably "take walks" and "go outside.") No part of the threat-type substance offered yesterday was serious. I'm not going to poison anyone's search results.

I was just referencing this famous Liam Neeson thing:

As for Weiss, I hopped aboard the outrage express in the manner that the generally loathsome Gawker and Jezebel do for most of their clicks. If I'd thought about this Daily article more I would have realized that this proposal was in no way going anywhere, but I took the cheap, easy route. While the goal of preventing a Michigan version of We Are ND is a laudable one, firing up the internet outragemobile is likely to get out of control and I should know better.

Seriously, though: just stop. Nothing good can come of this quest.

Now, like, call it. One of my top eleven subjects to rant about in recent times has been offenses flinging ineligible guys downfield on pass plays with impunity. Boy does that put a bee up my bonnet. Spielman, too.

It appears the hue and cry has made it to the lawmakers of our sport:

The ineligible downfield rule was shifted from three yards to one yard past the line of scrimmage. National officiating coordinator Rogers Redding said defenses were beginning to read run more frequently because offensive linemen were 3 yards downfield and then the quarterback would pass. “It's going to be easier to officiate,” he said.

Or, like, six yards downfield blocking the people who were supposed to be covering passes. One or three doesn't help much if you're just forgetting to enforce it either way; hopefully this will come with an increased emphasis on calling illegal men downfield.

(One exception: if you're engaged with a guy and just kicking his ass enough to end up downfield that should be let go. Taylor Lewan got a penalty a couple years ago because his pass blocking was too effective.)

Approximate top eleven rant subjects in recent times. Give or take:

  1. Dave Brandon
  2. excessive basketball timeouts
  3. block/charge calls
  4. Big Ten expansion
  5. bubble screens
  6. "but the spread won't work in the Big Ten"
  7. piped in music
  8. ineligible men downfield
  9. waggles
  10. Tom Izzo press conferences
  11. when my wife puts the cheese grater in with the food manipulation devices (tongs, spoons, spatulas, etc) instead of the food reconfiguration devices (juicers, graters, mallets, zesters, etc)

This is not 'Nam, MGoWife.

Nyet. Roquan Smith will announce his decision on Friday, whereupon he won't sign an letter of intent. He'll just sign scholarship papers. Well done, sir. (It seems like it's a foregone conclusion that it's not Michigan, unfortunately.)

Add another to the list? If Justice Hayes goes and rips off 1,500 yards I'm gonna be all like ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

I'm looking forward to a running backs coach with aspirations.

We would like less football, I guess. It's time once again for a college football person to mutter about changing clock rules For The Fans. Larry Scott's turn, as he advocate running the clock after first downs:

"You'll always get traditionalists who won't change it," Scott said. "I don't find it concerning or daunting that there are some that would oppose it. I think the job for commissioners is to take a step back and look at it holistically. The health and welfare of student-athletes is first and fans are a close second in terms of keeping games appealing. Three-and-a-half hours, to me, is too long."

There will always be traditionalists who are your core customers who know you're not seeing increased costs but still soaking fans with higher prices and ever-longer commercial breaks.

Why might games be longer?

The high-pressure, commercialized world of FBS is playing a much longer game than other NCAA divisions. While FBS games averaged 3:23 in 2014, the Football Championship Subdivision was 2:55, Division II was 2:45 and Division III was 2:41.

I mean:

Sun Belt commissioner Karl Benson also favors a running clock after first downs, citing declining attendance. FBS home attendance dropped 4 percent in 2014 for the sport's lowest average since 2000.

"I think our fans are expecting shorter games, and I think when you see attendance is down, we need to address it," Benson said.

Changing the ratio of game to red-hat-on-field the wrong way isn't going to help your attendance, but you don't actually care about that anyway. Just be honest about it. At this point it might be worth looking at some soccer models, which have to deal with an un-interruptible flow of gameplay. I'd rather have a logo next to the score chryon instead of ever-expanding ad time.

Early signing is dumb. Andy Staples addresses it:

I don’t mind an early signing period in theory because the vast majority of recruits know where they want to go, are happy with their decisions and shouldn’t have to wait. But cutting a month off of the process isn’t going to change much. It might be nice if the players who make up their minds really early had a chance to sign before their senior seasons begin, but that isn’t going to happen, either. Athletic directors would hate that since it would make it more difficult to fire a coach if he underperformed. The coach would have the leverage of half a signing class in the barn, and the AD might have to wrestle with double-digit players asking to be released from their National Letters of Intent. This happens all the time in basketball, but it’s different when the coach has 15 players signed instead of three.

Staples advocates a change to the LOI that says "the LOI is a bad thing to sign," so that's not… likely. To reiterate my excellent plan:

The MGo Recruitin' Plan

  1. You can sign a pre-NLI any time.

  2. The pre-NLI guarantees you a scholarship at the school you sign with, allows them to contact you whenever and prohibits other coaches from doing so. You can only take an official visit to the school you sign with.

  3. You can withdraw the pre-NLI at any time.

  4. On Signing Day everyone makes it official.

  5. (Optional but highly desirable) NCAA does away with 85-player cap and allows everyone to sign up to 22-25 players a year, no exceptions. Transfers and JUCOs count.

Changing the cap from a roster limit to a yearly limit instantly does away with any oversigning mutterings since your motivation is to keep players instead of cut them.

(Via Get The Picture.)

Karan Higdon will help you with your homework. Unless you're a fellow athlete, I think that's a violation. Randos welcome though:

"Football comes second to academics and my future after it."

Higdon's a 4.0 student at Riverview. He wants to be an occupational therapist. He's involved in several academic leadership groups at his school, and has been invited to various academic summits, from Washington D.C. to Paris.

If Higdon couldn't run, catch, block or score a touchdown, he'd probably still be headed to college next year with a scholarship in tow.

Academics aren't just part of the deal for Higdon. They're the deal.

I guess he doesn't want an MFA, or he'd be at Iowa. If Fred Jackson was still here he could be a grad transfer and get drafted, maybe.

Etc.: Orson is so fascinated with Tom Crean that he wrote about him. Michigan was the 12th most-watched team in college football last year, which really says something since… uh… you know. NTDP camp thoughts featuring comments on a few Michigan recruits. SBNation has a "Jim Harbaugh is weird" page. Tom Leyden on Bo's passing.

LeVert still projected 15th by DX. Noted Michigan columnist Ramzy Nasrallah on Harbaugh as nemesis.

Comments

Chunks the Hobo

February 12th, 2015 at 3:30 PM ^

My absolutely No. 1 most-hated Error That Is Now So Ubiquitous It Will Never Be Purged is the misuse of "begging the question." People use it in place of "raising the question" or "prompting the question." However, it actually refers to the logical fallacy of assuming an argument's conclusion as a premise.

This widespread misuse of "begging the question" is extra distressing because there is no other real concise way to say this, whereas there are multiple perfectly fine and already existing ways to say something brings up a question.

zapata

February 12th, 2015 at 4:07 PM ^

that is a big one. The one that drives me most crazy, and which is used frequently on these boards, is "dominate" when the adjective form, "dominant" is required. For example: "OSU was totally dominate in the championship game." Oh well, language is always changing. I prefer to see it change from the addition of new things than because people don't know what the hell they are saying, but oh well.... 

gbdub

February 12th, 2015 at 4:32 PM ^

I think that one just comes from people dropping the second "n" when they pronounce "dominant". So they try to spell it like they say it "dominat" and it autocorrects? Or maybe they just see "dominate" and pronounce it "dominat" in adjective form?

I don't think I've ever actually heard someone say "OSU was do-min-ate" so I think it's just a misspelling rather than actual confusion about the word.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

zapata

February 13th, 2015 at 10:32 AM ^

writing dominate when you mean dominant represents a lack/loss of understanding of how meaning is conveyed by language. Your/you're, or their/they're/there are just the same kind of misspellings, and maybe we'll eventually lose those distinctions and let context sort it out, but if people don't know the difference between them, I consider it poor use of language.

jmdblue

February 12th, 2015 at 4:43 PM ^

Overcorrecting improper English by going with "I" instead of "me" in all instances ie: "Jeff will be going to the game with Rachel and I"....  or even worse "I and Rachel."

"verbiage" doesn't just mean language one uses as in "Why don't we just change the verbiage in this section".  Rather it describes language as tiresome and verbose.

and last.... putting the possessive apostrophe on "its" ie: "The fawn will be cared for by it's mother",

I've learned in the last couple years that "ambivalent" doesn't mean "doesn't much care about one option over another due to indifference" .  It means "is extremely passionate about both options and can't decide which way to go causing great discomfort."  This is not a pet peave, but I now like the word much more.

I know.  I'm a prick.

Cheers.

Blau

February 12th, 2015 at 1:42 PM ^

Great UV today. Content was spot on. 

 

-- In the mea culpa segment, I imagined Chris Farley's Bennett Brower from SNL saying he doesn't "take walks" or "go outside". lol for realz.

-- Also I don't see a need to change the clock rules for first downs. Besides, a lot more teams are using hurry up offenses to take advantage of slow defenses getting back in position after 1st downs anyway. The only people holding up the clock I see are the refs spotting the ball. 

dragonchild

February 12th, 2015 at 1:45 PM ^

Dave Brandon - well duh.  At least he's gone.  By the way, does MGoBlog need a chief media officer?
excessive basketball timeouts - yes, there are way too many of them.  When a CLOSE 4th quarter score makes it MORE likely I'm going to turn a game off, it's broken.  If it's a one-score game with a minute left I just know it's going to take thirty minutes of fouls, time-outs, free throws and commercials.  A sport -- a high-level close game no less -- should NOT feel like rush-hour traffic.  And speaking of fouls. . .
block/charge calls - any sport where athletes are literally coached on flopping techniques is broken.  Yes that includes soccer as well.  Doesn't mean the sport is beyond hope; it's like a high-performance car with a smashed windshield.  It's still quite valuable to me; just fix the fucking damage already instead of pretending it can't be improved.
Big Ten expansion - not a terrible idea; terrible execution.
bubble screens - can we put this to rest?  Borges is gone.
"but the spread won't work in the Big Ten" - This too?  Ohio State just won the NC FFS.
piped in music - yes.  Michigan has a great band that is criminally underutilized.
ineligible men downfield - Also illegal chevron formations where the tackles are 3 yards behind the LoS.
waggles - Harbaugh will make you fall in love with them again.
Tom Izzo press conferences - why the mute button was invented.
when my wife puts the cheese grater in with the food manipulation devices (tongs, spoons, spatulas, etc) instead of the food reconfiguration devices (juicers, graters, mallets, zesters, etc) - I think you're beyond help.  By the way, does MGoBlog need a chief media officer?

Mr. Yost

February 12th, 2015 at 1:47 PM ^

...but that just makes me want to throw up.

Freddy Jackson should've never seen a day after Jeremy Jackson - and even that is pushing it, but it would've at least been understandable.

Goodness gracious that was one of the worst coaching staffs ever assembled. FOUR coaches (Nuss, Heck, Mattison, Manning) that should be coaching at the major CFB level. I guess if I'm counting Borges, I have to count Montgomery, so FIVE.

And it's not like the other 7 are even low-major CFB talent...they're MAC, Mountain West, Sun Belt level coaches.

That is just embarrassing.

NoVaWolverine

February 12th, 2015 at 1:49 PM ^

Beilein's non-negotiable policy of sitting players with two fouls in the first half, no matter the circumstance, has always been a big pet peeve of Brian's (and is maybe the only possible thing for which JB can be justly criticized). Very surprised it didn't make the list of his "top rant subjects in recent times."

Just sayin'.

Alton

February 12th, 2015 at 2:28 PM ^

Is there any statistical evidence that calling a timeout during an opponent's run is a superior strategy to not calling a timeout during an opponent's run?

I don't know.  There is probably some small gain to calling the timeout, but of course there is a corresponding loss, in that the team now has one fewer timeout to call when they might need it even more. 

It would certainly be a good research opportunity for somebody with more progamming skills than I have.

Fuzzy Dunlop

February 12th, 2015 at 2:36 PM ^

Something can be both funny and bad-natured at the same time.  See, e.g., 50% of all insults leveled in high school.  

Brian correctly realized that putting a 19-year old on blast by posting a goofy photo of him was ill-advised.  But if this is the hill you want to die on, so be it.  

Wendyk5

February 12th, 2015 at 3:00 PM ^

I actually didn't immediately connect it with "Taken" and thought he was 50/50 being real. I saw the over-the-top humor in it, but also thought he was 50% genuinely pissed off enough to maybe do something punitive. I mean, it's not as if Brian hasn't flown off the handle before, and this song idea is so Dave Brandon-esque, the anger seemed plausible enough. 

 

 

MC5-95

February 12th, 2015 at 1:56 PM ^

Even with excessive basketball timeouts, you can still watch a game in two hours or less usually. Football games going over 3 hours is a bit ridiculous, and last season for a Michigan fan was so very painful. (Though I have to say I ended up DVR fast forwarding through most Michigan 4th quarters last year, sad as it is to admit it.)

bronxblue

February 12th, 2015 at 2:28 PM ^

I'm glad Brian came forward and see the record straight for those who thought his post was wrong; I didn't see much of an issue but credit to Brian for acknowleding actual dissenting opinions and not just concern trolls.  

It's still a dumb idea for a song, though.

Jinkin Mongol

February 12th, 2015 at 2:37 PM ^

Ha, wait until your baby is born and sleep deprivation kicks in.  Compared with what is coming the cheese grater incidents will feel like your time together back by the lake on Naboo. 

dragonchild

February 12th, 2015 at 5:34 PM ^

I don't know who you are. I don't know what you want. If you are looking for the cheese grater, I can tell you I don't have one. But what I do have are a very particular set of skills, skills I have acquired over a very long career. Skills that make me a nightmare for people like you. If you let me load the dishwasher now, that'll be the end of it. I will not look for you, I will not pursue you. But if you don't, I will look for you, I will find you, and I will make you wash the dishes by hand.

Zone Left

February 12th, 2015 at 2:47 PM ^

I'd rather reduce quarter length to 12 minutes and keep 1st down time stoppages. They extend the percentage of the game a team in a given situation can make a comeback.

funkywolve

February 12th, 2015 at 2:53 PM ^

of spread offenses and 3 play scoring drives I don't think getting rid of the clock stopping after first downs is going to put in a major dent in the overall game time in D1 division.  The reason the difference is probably so great between D1, 1-AA, D2 etc. is TV timeouts/commercials.  When you look at the scores from any given Saturday and most of the scores are 45-27, 42-28, etc.  the amount of time spent going to commercial breaks after scores is huge. 

ST3

February 12th, 2015 at 3:36 PM ^

When a team scores a TD in the NFL, I know I can walk away for 10 minutes and not miss anything of importance. The next 10 minutes include:

0-2 min: Unnecessarily long review of scoring play

2-2:30: extra point

2:30-6:00: commercials

6:00-6:30: kickoff that goes out of the endzone in the interest of player safety

6:30-9:30: more commercials

9:30-10:00: replays of scoring play

and we're back ready for play...

Blake

February 12th, 2015 at 3:00 PM ^

I think that instead of trying to find ways to shorten the game such as the running clock after 1st downs (or when players go out of bounds), they should instead find a way to make the game shorter for those who are watching it in the stadium.

Fans at the stadium aren't watching the commercials that the broadcasts are showing to those at home, so why have them at all? Instead you could make the in-stadium experience like watching a game on a DVR.

- Start the in-stadium and tv broadcast at the same time

- Every time tv takes a timeout for commercials, don't take that timeout in the stadium and just continue playing

- After the commercial break concludes, the tv wouldn't miss any of the action, they would just broadcast the game as if it were being tape delayed slightly by the length of the commercial break.

One of the benefits is that it would create a premium for going to the game (and by their rationale, increase attendance since the at home experience would be a moderately diminished product) -- you would truly be witnessing every event live while the tv action may be behind by 5 minutes by the end of the 1st quarter, 10 minutes by half, etc.

The networks may not buy it, but it's overdue for them to throw a bone to the people actually at the games.

 

 

akim

February 12th, 2015 at 3:01 PM ^

These stories on Karan Higdon are really cool.  It's nice to see how he has so much drive on and off the field.  The story of him even making it up to Michigan despite that snowstorm is really something.  I'm excited to see him compete and succeed at Michigan.