Unverified Voracity Eulogizes Troll Comment Count

Brian

So... how did that happen? Ohio State lost to Penn State over the weekend. You may not be aware of this so I will pause for your chortling.

...

All right. Done? No?

...

how bout now nvm

...

cumong man

...
cumong

...

Okay. Now we can proceed. While OSU losing to Penn State, a team Michigan beat 49-10, has caused no end of merriment in the Michigan fan base*, there was an awful lot of flukiness in the PSU win. OSU outgained PSU by a wide margin, held them to under 300 yards of offense, and had a 64% win expectancy per S&P+. PSU made up the deficit with two huge special teams plays, the first a blocked punt that set up a field goal to pull them within four, the second a kick-six that turned an potential 7-point OSU lead into the three point deficit they'd lose by.

Normally I'd write those off as flukes not applicable to the Game, but Michigan has already blocked six kicks this year and has Jabrill Peppers sitting back there for any teams who want to get overly concerned about getting the punt off. Advantage: Michigan.

Meanwhile, PFF's evaluation contains some shocking stats about the OSU OL:

...the entire unit struggled in pass protection, surrendering a staggering 34 pressures between them, with RT Isaiah Prince accounting for almost half of those by himself. The spark of Curtis Samuel’s untouched 74-yard touchdown run and Marcus Baugh’s tackle-breaking exploits in the first quarter weren’t repeated in the final 25 minutes of the game.

And it could have been worse for OSU. Star Nittany Lion DE Garrett Sickels sat out the first half. This did not prevent him from racking up 2.5 sacks. A different PFF article has a different pressure number but it's still boggling: 28 pressures on 53 dropbacks. Taco Charlton and Chris Wormley are likely to do similar work. PSU's 28th in adjusted sack rate. Michigan is 4th.

A second major issue was an inability to get to Saquon Barkley near the line of scrimmage:

the Penn State offensive line set up Barkley with 41 of his 99 rushing yards before contact, and Barkley didn’t have to break any tackles while coming up just a yard shy of a 100-yard game. The star on the offensive line for the third straight week was RT Brendan Mahon, who dominated the Ohio State front on the ground, combining particularly well on double teams to blow the Buckeyes’ defensive tackles out of the middle of the play and disrupt the linebackers behind them.

Later in that piece PFF will advocate for OSU's backup DTs to play over the starters after PSU and Wisconsin gashed OSU up the gut repeatedly. I will repeat: PSU—THE Penn State University—gashed Ohio State up the gut. Penn State. That one. That team. The one with Paris Palmer in the starting lineup again. They got 8.2 yards per carry between the tackles. (Why on Earth they only gave Barkley 12 carries is completely inexplic—oh right James Franklin.)

OSU's run D looks fine statistically, but that's largely due to 4 TEAM rushes for a total of –43 yards. Those were three kneels from the gun and a yakety snap over the punter's head. Remove those and Penn State rushed for an even 5 yards a carry without a single broken tackle from Barkley.

Michigan looks like they have a significant advantage on both lines. I can't believe I'm saying that but here we are.

*[My favorite thing is OSU fans saying it was a ROAD NIGHT GAME since Vegas is now offering 40 points for home field advantage.]

In other OSU issues. Land Grant Holy Land notes that OSU doesn't get many explosive plays. It's Curtis Samuel and that's it. In a very James Franklin twist, Samuel had two carries for 71 yards against PSU. And as always, I recommend Ross Fulton's OSU breakdown.

Meanwhile in this week's matchup. It doesn't look good for MSU:

How is Michigan State going to move the football?
I'm not sure how else to headline this bullet point. If you look at the numbers -- what Michigan's done on defense and what Michigan State's done on offense -- you get a pretty simple result. Michigan State will have to completely change the way it runs offense, overnight, and Michigan's defense will have to take a massive step backward for the Spartans to move the ball with consistency.

For the year, 22.2 percent of MSU's offensive possession have reached the red zone (No. 117 nationally). Michigan's defense, meanwhile, has allowed offenses to reach the red zone on just 6.7 percent of their possessions. That's No. 1 nationally. Michigan State also ranks near the bottom nationally in number of possessions per game at 12.6 and near the bottom in average field position. MSU is No. 91 nationally in rush yards per game, Michigan's No. 4 nationally in rush defense. If numbers hold, this could be a great day for Michigan's defense and a long one for MSU's offense.

MSU's gotta hope that some long bombs get completed and LJ Scott can conjure something up himself.

Bill Connelly gets to talk about his numbers too. We've been doing it all year, and he joins the "holy crap, Michigan's defense in S&P+" brigade:

Def. S&P+ is presented in an adjusted points-per-game figure and is created from an opponent-adjusted mix of efficiency, explosiveness, finishing drives, turnover factors, and field position factors. Here are its top five defenses in the country:

5. Wisconsin (12.4 Adj. PPG)
4. Alabama (11.9)
3. Florida (11.3)
2. Clemson (11.0)
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
1. Michigan (0.8)

0.8!

Yes, these numbers are adjusted for garbage time, so Jim Harbaugh’s general ruthlessnessisn’t giving the Wolverines an added statistical advantage.

Yes, these numbers are adjusted for opponent, though while Michigan’s schedule was supposedto be awful, it really hasn’t been; among Wolverine victims, Wisconsin is 10th in overall S&P+, Penn State is 16th, and Colorado is 17th.

29782633160_5e92a015cb_z

[Eric Upchurch]

Jim Harbaugh is crazy part infinity. SBN notes that Harbaugh does things without knowing what the score is. Deadspin gets into Harbaugh's inability to let that fourth-quarter spot go, and I make note of the latter mostly to highlight a couple of comments. One:

When Tomsula wouldn’t let anything go, you called him a hoarder and impounded his car.

Two:

He was my daughter’s micro-soccer coach when she and his kid were 4 years old. He couldn’t have been nicer, more mellow, or better liked by the kids. He adapts to every situation to be great at whatever it is.

I almost don't want to believe the latter.

Baumgardner pokes the bear. Cumong man:

No disrespect, Michigan State, but Michigan's focused on bigger things for 2016

That's probably worth a field goal, that headline.

Harbaugh is worth it. Financially, things are going swimmingly:

U-M's overall revenue in spectator admissions increased to $45.1 million during the 2016 fiscal year, compared to $41.9 million in 2015. The $3.2 million increase was primarily due to an increase in football ticket demand, according to the financial analysis, which was approved by the U-M Board of Regents on Thursday, Oct. 20.

In comparison, spectator admissions decreased $8.3 million in 2015 due to a decrease in football, men's basketball and ice hockey admissions.

Overall, the athletic department saw an increase of $7.8 million to its net position for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2016, which is up from 2015's $1 million overall increase.

He literally pays for himself, and that's before various other application/donation things get factored in.

RIP Drew Sharp, troll. People should memorialize the dead as they knew them. Much of the Detroit media has done so in the case of Drew Sharp, who passed away at 56 this Friday. Those who knew him say he was a great and funny guy whose button-pushing writing shouldn't define the man, and I won't dispute that.

However, much of the memorializing has bothered me because it skips straight over the lasting fact of Drew Sharp's career: he was an unrepentant troll. There is a certain genre of newspaper columnist or radio talking head that is relentlessly negative because that's the only thing he can do that gets a reaction, and Sharp was Detroit's version. (There's one in every city.) He didn't have readers. He had marks.

His cynicism was breathtaking, and this was never more clear than in the immediate aftermath of Michigan signing Demar Dorsey. Sharp correctly diagnosed that circus as desperation on the part of Rich Rodriguez, but for the wrong reason. Dorsey was nowhere close to qualifying and never came close, spending his career at various vagabond stops en route to a brief Arena League career. It's a sad story about kids who come up rough and can't make it out.

Or, if you're Drew Sharp, it's an opportunity to bash a teenager who ended up in trouble:

MATT SHEPARD: "He was timed with a 4.4—"
SHARP: "Avoiding police."

SHEPARD: "That happened when he was 16 and he was acquitted.
SHARP: "I wonder if that was because he was a high profile recruit. Hmm. I wonder. … OJ got acquitted. Being acquitted doesn't mean you're innocent."

That's the only thing he ever did that made me legitimately angry; the rest of it was eye-rolling at his transparent attempts to troll people. I only knew his writing, so I knew him as a man with contempt for everything and an utter lack of empathy.

Meanwhile his writing level and banter was barely above every message board's worst poster. Deadspin got its hands on a couple of his Brandon-esque emails some years back, and since those come through without the benefit of seven layers of editing they're the clearest picture of his talent as a writer.

WAAAAAH! WAAAAAH!
Does the little baby need a pacifier?
Yeah, Detroit needs writers that makes excuses for the city and simply tell the idiots in this town just want to hear.
They've been doing that for 30 years in this town and that's a big reason why Detroit is swirling down the toilet.
Oh, I'm sorry...that's not a "happy feel good story" is it?
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!

He had none. Drew Sharp's death is a loss to those who knew him. His career is his career, though, and shouldn't be viewed through sepia-tinged glasses. It says something that most of the newspaper obits start with "if you look past the thing he did every day for the last 30 years, he was a great guy." Mmmhmm.

Etc.: Nebraska regent reacts to players' kneeling protest badly. Nobody on the NTDP is a first round lock this year but two Michigan commits are candidates. Hockey also picked up a commit from D Mike Vukojevic, a potential first round OHL draft pick. Brendan Quinn on Xavier Simpson.  Kill 'em with kindness. Also your DL.

Comments

laus102

October 25th, 2016 at 1:48 PM ^

Man that shit really pisses me off.  

When african americans protest violently: "This is harmful, why can't you protest in a more peaceful way?"

When african americans protest peacefully: "This is harmful, why can't you protest in a more constructive way?"

I just don't fucking get it man.  Such a double standard.  They can't win.  

 

Medic

October 25th, 2016 at 4:53 PM ^

This has nothing to with whether they're protesting violently or not. A lot of those emails are unfortunate but the last one was spot on. 

The issue is this:

While those indiividuals certainly have the right to express themselves, they do not explicity have the right to put on that uniform and then protest in a way that does not represent the university or it's opinion, of which there shouldn't be one. In other words, your (or their in this case) opinion does not represent the opinion of the university or its alumni and therefore has no place in that setting.

If they want to protest they can join any number of activist groups on campus, *out of uniform* and express their right to protest any social injustices. It also is a disservice to the kids that are protesting because they may feel this is ok to do in private or public sector jobs. The vast majority of employers, were they to pull a stunt like this on their future job, would get fired immediately. Does YOUR opinion represent the opinion of your company at large in regards to social issues? More than likely no and even if it did, they may not want YOU using your position in such a way to represent the views of the company. 

taistreetsmyhero

October 26th, 2016 at 12:55 AM ^

That's bullshit. Everything you wrote goes counter to the idea of a Michigan man. There's a freaking saying about how you are an ambassador of your program. By recruiting these young men and selecting them into their university, they collectively have become the voice of the university.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

Medic

October 26th, 2016 at 3:23 PM ^

They ARE ambassadors of the program, you and I agree on that. Which is why they shouldn't use that platform to forward PERSONAL opinions.

I guess I should have taken a knee on the pooldeck at Canham to protest the Iraq war in 92? Would I have my Michigan Man street cred then? Do I represent the views of the school or its alumni? Of course not. I represent myself and MY beliefs. I have basically forfiet my goodwill by projecting personal views into my role as an ambassdor for the school. It has no place in athletics.

 

blueblue

October 25th, 2016 at 1:50 PM ^

I think it should matter to us how we're rememberd by the public, and the public should be honest and remember us how we were in life. If you care what people think of you and how you're remembered, you're less likely to act like a dick. 

Sam1863

October 25th, 2016 at 2:16 PM ^

When Sharp died, I saw the columns from other media members swearing what a good and wonderful man he was. I had no reason to doubt their opinion. They knew him personally as a friend and colleague, while I only knew him publicly as a columnist.

But that columnist was an obnoxious reactionary, a provocateur who purposely found what was popular just so he could throw mud at it. One writer said that Sharp loved “wearing the black hat.” Maybe so, but that’s not the mark of a professional journalist. That’s the mark of somebody who’s flipping off the public for kicks, of the pimply teenager who’s getting back at the cool kids for not letting him sit at their lunch table.

When his drivel would boil my blood and I would post a reply on the Freep’s message board, I would refer to him as “Bitter Little Drewie.” Even after I wised up and stopped reading his clickbait, I still thought of him that way. His public persona may have been an act, but it was an act he found awfully easy to play.

wolvemarine

October 25th, 2016 at 2:48 PM ^

...for me why most newspapers are utter garbage.

I have read more interesting columns, better statistical breakdowns, learned more about football -- even a little basketball through my thick-headed skull -- from the writers on this site in eighteen months than I have from every dullard newspaper writer, loudmouth tv bozo, and radio mouthbreather in the last ten years.

Albom pablum, Bayless idiocy, Rome's tiresome snark, the gimmicry of PTI...and Sharp's lackwit simpleminded negativity.

Great guy?  Maybe so to those who knew him.  Great writer?  No.  He wrote garbage.

Saying everyone and everything sucks isn't talent.

 

Lawyer12

October 25th, 2016 at 2:51 PM ^

The man is dead. I'm very disappointed that anyone thinks it's necessary to say anything negative. If that's your opinion, or even a fact, keep it to yourself and move on. No class.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

CantRead-CantWrite

October 25th, 2016 at 2:54 PM ^

While I appreciate a brave and honest opinion from you Brian, some things could've been left unsaid about Sharp in the wake of his death.  Maybe it's just me, but I've always been taught not to speak ill of the dead.  I'm disappointed to see what has been written.

CantRead-CantWrite

October 25th, 2016 at 4:01 PM ^

I don't intend to come from a place of moral superiority over anybody, I'm just providing my opinion of what I perceive to be good or poor taste.  Given the comments on this post I appear to be speaking as a minority with the view that the words about Sharp were simply bad form.

Ron Utah

October 25th, 2016 at 3:00 PM ^

Brian Cook - Speaker for the Dead

Highest compliment I have ever given (by far my favorite book of all-time) to Brian.

The dead should be treated with the same respect as the living, and honesty is far more valuable than sensitivity.

Lee Everett

October 25th, 2016 at 7:45 PM ^

Exactly.

You hope that you live a life worth talking about, that your work has made a lasting impact and that you've left the world in a better place than you found it.

If you haven't, you know. Your friends know. Your family knows.

When my father died, nobody talked about how great of a father or a husband he was, because it would have been a disservice to sugarcoat his life and say he was something he wasn't.
I'm glad nobody came up to me with bullshit, because it would have been exactly that.

Drew Sharp made choices every time he penned an article and as a public figure a lot of people were made aware of those choices. He had to live with how he made an income, and it isn't any less true now that he's gone.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

MGoBlueMyself

October 25th, 2016 at 3:46 PM ^

Couldn't believe the number of "Meyer needs to go" posts I saw on an OSU forum saturday. Nothing like a Texas or ND site right now, but more than you would expect for a guy who has won a NC, lost a total of 5 games in 5 years and just had his first true road loss at the university. 

No, but you're right, Pawl Finebawm. Michigan definitely has the most insufferable fan base.

jmblue

October 25th, 2016 at 3:57 PM ^

I don't understand this phenomenon of filiming yourself being upset when your team loses and uploading it to YouTube.  I've assumed it's all an act.

 

 

CoverZero

October 25th, 2016 at 5:02 PM ^

Speaking of Trolls.  The asshat baldy down in Alabama / SEC country refuses to praise Michigan and still believes that OSU will win out and represent the B1G in the title game.  He went on an on about it on CF Live yesterdary.

MGoUberBlue

October 25th, 2016 at 5:34 PM ^

The pencil necked geek is a monumental asshole.

I just don't see how he can have a key role at ESPN.  You know what he is going to say before he opens his mouth and is not objective in any possible manner.

It is quite clear that he has a boner for Jim Harbaugh that seems to be based on an inability to accept Harbaugh's obvious talents as a really really very good coach.  It would be the most delicious schadenfreude if Michigan makes the playoffs rather than OSU, advances to the Championship Game and then kicks ass in that game.  It may be optimistic but based on what we have seen this year, it could happen.

Go Blue!     

BursleyHall82

October 25th, 2016 at 5:11 PM ^

I was expecting Jeff Moss of DSR to unload on Drew Sharp after his death - and he did - but I really didn't expect it from Brian, and I'm disappointed. Yes, 99 percent of the people on this site hated what Drew wrote, didn't respect him, didn't think he had talent, thought he was lazy, thought he was whatever. We hated his work. Fine.

But he wasn't a surgeon who was bad at his job. Or a judge. Or a teacher. He was a sports columnist. What he did for a living didn't really matter in the grand scheme of things.

He died at the age of 56 of a heart attack, and he's leaving behind a grieving wife and a lot of grieving friends. His life mattered to them. The things you said should have been left unsaid.

M-GoGirl

October 25th, 2016 at 6:15 PM ^

until I have more pleasurable things to think about Saturday afternoon. Just perfect!

On Sharp, I didn't like him and agree with Brian's comments for the most part and respect his honesty.  I pretty much just didn't read Sharp. And I could never loathe him as much as I did (and do) loathe Michael Rosenberg. That's the difference between a troll and a tool, IMO.

Fezzik

October 25th, 2016 at 6:47 PM ^

I'm impressed with this post Brian. I absolutely hate how every single person who passes away is said to be loved by all and the greatest person ever. I recently read about a playboy model who passed and that "everything she did was for her daughter" in regards to her career. Yeah...she posed naked for the world to see for her 5 year old daughter I'm sure. I wish no ill words towards the deceased but lying is never necessary. Let's call a spade a spade.

littlee5122

October 26th, 2016 at 10:54 AM ^

Went back and watched the attached video a bit longer. Priceless but had to empathize with the OSU fan. Been there way too many times and not so long ago.

This season is like a dream. I'm thinking it's going to be historically the best ever (for me at least - I'm 57), especially if Speight can keep improving. More bye weeks??

Had to ask about the the OSU's guys' comment on pass interference. It seems with all the pushing and hand checking going on the refs let more go at the moment the ball arrives. That was always PI in the old days.

Same call with Julio Jones/Sherman last week. If your arm is being pulled down? C'mon

It seems as a DB you have to push the envelope until they call 'em and hope the final call in crunch time is at least consistent with the rest of the game.

Re: Sharp. I thought it was fair. He was the only writer ever to cause me to write a lengthy email trying to persuade him logically that he was literally poisoning the best parts of sports with his style of writing and with subtle (I was trying to be nice) changes he could be so much more interesting and value added. I know...pretty lame