Michigan 27, Northwestern 19 Comment Count

Ace


via @cjzero, obviously

I can't. I just... I can't. Thank you, Northwestern, for being Northwestern.

Consider this an open thread to celebrate(!) a victory(!!) featuring multiple touchdowns!!!

(Shhhhhhh, don't ruin it by mentioning the multiple overtimes part.)


Bryan Fuller/MGoBlog

Comments

WolverineHistorian

November 16th, 2013 at 9:04 PM ^

This is Northwestern the last 6 weeks:

Oct. 5th against OSU: A fumbled snap on 4th and 1 with a bad spot from the refs kills their last drive to tie the game.  Lost 40-30.

Oct. 12th against Wisconsin: Dead from the start.  Lifeless.  Lost 35-6.

Oct. 19th against Minnesota: Two fourth quarter turnovers blow their lead which the Gophers turn into 14 points to pull out the win.  Lost 20-17

Oct. 26th against Iowa: A fourth quarter comeback is cut short and they come up with no points in overtime.  Lost 17-10

Nov. 2nd against Nebraska: A 3 point lead with just 6 seconds left.  Nebraska's third string QB comes in and completes a miracle hail mary.  Lost 27-24.

Nov. 16th against Michigan: 93 dropped interceptions, a regained fumble in OT by UM, a miracle field goal kicked in regulation with 1 second left, Al Borges, Al Borges, Al Borges, Al Borges. Lose 27-19. 

That's a whole lot of suck.  And bad luck. 

harmon98

November 16th, 2013 at 9:08 PM ^

Willie Henry had himself a ballgame. Good for him.

Team 134 plays hard. Great effort out there. 

We beat America. On the road. I'll celebrate the win dammit.

Red is Blue

November 16th, 2013 at 9:40 PM ^

Got to give kudos to refs for getting ball spotted quickly.  But, some of the holding going on was amazing with no calls.  On separate plays, I saw C. Gordon, Bolden and Charlton either get tackled or completely turned around.  Also, looked like we had a few as well.  Is holding now legal?

The Iron Jock

November 16th, 2013 at 9:19 PM ^

Seriously. I do not blame Devin for any of this. The kid is a keeper, despite his troubles, which I am certain stem from the offensive offensive coaching staff. (No typo. I meant to say that.) Michigan survived today despite Al Borges. Saturday evening quarterbacks lauding Hoke for going for it instead of kicking the field goal should shut their mouths now. I am typically aggressive in these situations but in a 9-6 game, going for it in the red zone when you have Michigan's offense in that moment is insanity. In this case, they won but I can't help but think that, hopefully, Hoke left Borges to his own devices in that moment as a way of letting what will be be. But now, who knows. I just hope that regardless of how this season ends, there is a complete and thorough evaluation of the coaching staff. If that happens, I am confident that Borges won't pass muster. Go Blue. Love this blog. Out. 

kb

November 17th, 2013 at 1:09 AM ^

While I love his effort he makes some of the worst in game decisions I have ever seen a quarterback make.....if NW defense could catch they might have had two or three pick sixes. For a junior he should be better than that. He is just as much a problem as the coaching.

JilesDauz

November 17th, 2013 at 5:26 AM ^

x10000. There was a play where he essentially threw a perfectly timed out to the NW linebacker who dropped it. It's as if Devin spent his week in evanston practicing throwing balls to their linebackers.

 

There's no excuse for that kinda play this late in his career. We have to go with Morris at the start of next season. (Preferably now but that's a pipe dream. LIke firing Borges)

In reply to by JilesDauz

wahooverine

November 17th, 2013 at 3:29 PM ^

"Late in his career". let's remember that Gardner is a 1st year starter. While he is a junior, he also has been in three different scenes in that time. RR, Post-RR DRob hybrid offense and now Borges ball. This supposed learning progression from which you expect him to never make a mistake ever and be like AJ McCarrin is a figment of your imagination.

He does make some bad choices like any 1st year starter. but many of his mistakes come from the terrible protection he gets. That makes any qb look bad. Give Gardner time to throw and you get the ND game.

He is not the problem.

DelhiGoBlue

November 18th, 2013 at 1:11 AM ^

Been following Michigan football too well.  Are you saying Devin Gardner never started a game at Michigan, as QB, before the CMU?  He didn't start any games last year and he never practiced as QB before August of this year? 

If you're going to puff up a player at least be factual.  As for "the problem", no he isn't "THE" problem, but he is "A" problem and to believe otherwise is simply simple minded no matter how much of the alphabet you have after your name.

bighouse22

November 17th, 2013 at 10:32 AM ^

His play can be downright disastrous at times, but he is also the biggest weapon we have.  When he is put in the position to be a game manager (the last 3 games, less OT) you see how limited this team is on offense.  When he just plays, you get what he did against ND and in OT.  He is Michigan's biggest playmaker and the only reason they have won 7 games this year with a weak OL.  His biggest issues are staring down WRs, waiting until they get open (rather than throwing to a spot), and trying to not make mistakes.

Mistakes are part of the learning process!  Some of you may remember how bad Griese was the year before the NC.  I was crushed that he was starter the following year and was wrong when he lead the team to an undefeated season!

The Iron Jock

November 17th, 2013 at 7:57 PM ^

I agree that he does make some funky -- alright, bad -- decisions sometimes but really, can we blame that on him entirely? Seriously, the guy was recruited to do one thing, shoehorned into doing something else at quarterback, recommissioned as a wide receiver, and then moved back to quarterback to run some hybrid deal that the offensive coordinator never really bought into in the first place. And then this year, he was probably ordered not to run, a la Denard, so as not to get hurt, and then got traumatized by some early picks. Who knows what the coaches are telling him. I have to be honest, if Borges goes all Borges over the next two weeks, I'd like to see Devin start calling audibles. The kid is an athlete. Let him do what he needs to do to win the freakin' games.

 

The Iron Jock

November 17th, 2013 at 7:57 PM ^

I agree that he does make some funky -- alright, bad -- decisions sometimes but really, can we blame that on him entirely? Seriously, the guy was recruited to do one thing, shoehorned into doing something else at quarterback, recommissioned as a wide receiver, and then moved back to quarterback to run some hybrid deal that the offensive coordinator never really bought into in the first place. And then this year, he was probably ordered not to run, a la Denard, so as not to get hurt, and then got traumatized by some early picks. Who knows what the coaches are telling him. I have to be honest, if Borges goes all Borges over the next two weeks, I'd like to see Devin start calling audibles. The kid is an athlete. Let him do what he needs to do to win the freakin' games.

 

jvocke

November 16th, 2013 at 9:22 PM ^

... happy for the win.  Looking at the gif though - were we set?  I'm looking specifically at the top of the screen at the right most player who is on the line of scrimmage.  Hard to tell from a gif, but I think we may have gotten away with one there.  Nevertheless, it was an amazing effort and execution just to get M in the position to have the chance.

Go Blue!

mgoblue98

November 16th, 2013 at 9:30 PM ^

I didn't see the whole game, but the part that I did see Michigan was running zone blocking, especially out of shotgun formation. Did they do that in the last half of the third quarter and the fourth quarter as well?

blusage

November 16th, 2013 at 9:38 PM ^

Let's get some thing straight: I think we all are happy for the players on the team. We ALL value their commitment and hard work. Those of us that are unhappy about the coaching are thinking of the players even more than the head-in-sand fans who go around pretending that everything is fine.

The players in any football program put in roughly the same time committment. I'd rather have our Michigan players be rewarded for their efforts by giving them a coach that can teach them to win against the best in the country. We don't have that. I'm not going to sit here and say that's okay. The MIchigan Wolverines deserve a better coach, a better program, better wins, and better results.

But that's just me. If squeaking by Northwestern in 3OTs is signs of progress for you and a personal wellspring of euphoria, go in peace, brother.

M-Wolverine

November 16th, 2013 at 9:42 PM ^

No coach at Michigan has ever satisfied you and you'll accept nothing less than multiple national championships that meet the same high standard of success you hold yourself to. You can stop posting; we got it the first 78 times you posted it.

SalvatoreQuattro

November 16th, 2013 at 11:41 PM ^

Teams have bad years. It happens.  Yes, this season has sucked and yes there needs to be staff changes.(looks at Funk and Borges). But even the best programs struggle sometimes.

 

Continuously bitching about the same shit over and over again when we all know what the issue is does nothing but irritates other people.

User -not THAT user

November 17th, 2013 at 11:04 AM ^

"If squeaking by Northwestern in 3OTs is signs of progress for you and a personal wellspring of euphoria, go in peace, brother. "

This.

The only difference between the NW win and the wins over Akron and UConn is three losses in between.  It's hard to feel especially good about this result because of the nature of the opponent and the flukish nature of the win.  It doesn't give any indication that Michigan is progressing as a team in as much as they finally managed to play a team that sucks worse than them.

Honestly, I'm ready for this year to be over...I can't remember ever feeling this way about Michigan football, even during RichRod's first year.  Even then I was optimistic that things would get better.  But with this staff I just don't see anything better than a three-loss season regardless of whether they have "their players" or "their system" in effect.  They just don't have the imagination to bring out the players' abilities beyond that.

And it sucks, too...when Ohio State wants a good coach, they go out and get a good coach.  They are rewarded for firing Jim Tressel with a single 6-7 season purgatory and then they hire Urban Meyer, who hasn't lost since the 2009 SEC Championship game.  Michigan hires, then fires one of the finest offensive minds in all of football and gets...Hoke and Change.  From Sugar Bowl champions in 2011 to re-living RichRod's third season in 2013. 

And I'm not even saying Michigan has a birth rite to compete for the MNC every year...I'd just like for them to compete for the B1G and beat OSU on a regular if not constant basis.  For the University of Michgan to go  ten years without winning its conference is just...well, it's never happened in my lifetime, but admittedly I'm only 46.  Maybe it happened during the Eisenhower administration, but I'd hate to think we've regressed that badly.  But as someone else pointed out with the Parcells quote, "you are what your record says you are", and except for the 2012 MNC run, Michigan is Notre Dame.

wahooverine

November 17th, 2013 at 8:27 PM ^

wah wah wah.  The team is stocked with young talent (much of which being blooded this year) and more on the way.  Is that an indicator of progress?   Wait you want Michigan to win the B10 and beat OSU? What a novel position to take.

The fine offensive mind that was fired put up nice numbers against the Umass's and Illinois of the world, then got shutdown against OSU and MSU.  As this fine mind went out the door, so too did one of the most embarrassing defensive minds in college football and in came one of the finest defensive minds in the NFL.  RR won 15 games total in 3 years.  Hoke won his 15th game around week 6 of his second year, while bringing in top 10 recruiting classes each year.  

So I guess I'm not following you, but sorry this season is displeasing.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

gbdub

November 18th, 2013 at 9:31 AM ^

Hate to break it to you, but the current set of minds has also gotten shut down by MSU and other good teams. We still haven't beat a .500 team on the road, and we haven't scored a TD in regulation since the Indiana game, despite playing two of the weakest defenses in the conference the last two weeks. This offense is GERGian right now.

erald01

November 16th, 2013 at 9:45 PM ^

The only thing i took out of the game is that OL got some confidence back and we were able to run the ball. Defense did a good job. And the guys played hard on the road.
But offense still needs work and most importantly DG needs some good coaching

One Inch Woody…

November 16th, 2013 at 9:50 PM ^

Zone blocking was very effective! But please for the love of god get rid of the zone stretch... It worked with Green for one his longer runs, but it leads to TFLs more commonly.

There was one sack from the 3-stack formation in which there were no receivers within 15 yards of the line of scrimmage on 3rd down. That is absolutely unacceptable.

What happened to jarrod Wilson?

robmorren2

November 16th, 2013 at 10:00 PM ^

I would rather see Michigan go for it on 4th&6 rather than 4th&2. Our playcalling on anything less than 2 yards to go is brutal. Were Gallon & Funchess both on the sideline for that 4th down play? Either way, horrible call. I'm ok with the decision to go for it, but Gardner can only bail out Borges so many times in one season with his legs. Lining up and asking #98 to run for it against 11 in the box is ludicrous.

WolverineFanatic6

November 16th, 2013 at 10:09 PM ^

I don't know how people really think we had marked improvement today. What game did you watch? I mean sure we didn't have negative rushing yards but we managed 330 Ish yards in 3 overtimes!!! We scored 27 points despite starting with the ball at or inside NW's 25 six or seven times I believe.

Optimism is great. I just didn't see an improvement. Had it been against a team with a pulse, sure. Northwestern is not a team with a pulse, they find ways to lose and they kept handing Michigan th game til Al finally decided to take it.

Atrained

November 16th, 2013 at 10:33 PM ^

We can talk all day about the deficiencies in the team this game displayed, but at the end of the day it's all about the players on the team. No one on that team put in thousands of hours of intensive work only to go through the disappointment they've faced. Whether or not this team was efficient, they played in a cold rain well into the evening, which is really, really tough. This may not be the most successful team but I couldn't be happier that those guys get to drive back to Ann Arbor happy and joyous for once. They could've crumbled many times in the game but they didn't, and they deserve to be proud.

mgoblue98

November 16th, 2013 at 10:39 PM ^

So tiny creases sounds about right. By plenty....do you mean like eight or ten? While I like Derrick Green and think he should get more carries, there hasn't been a whole lot of room for the RB's to run. Earlier in the year, Green was being tackled by blades of grass. It's nice to see him improve.

BlueGoM

November 16th, 2013 at 10:41 PM ^

Glad we won and everything, but we barely beat  an 0-6 B1G team,  after they could have had any number of interceptions.  A win, but a very ugly win.

Only sign of real improvement was some good push on the OL and some actual rushing yards.  But then we were playing NW... so... yeah.