Jim Harbaugh Is Not A Food Critic Comment Count

Ace


[Eric Upchurch/MGoBlog]

Jim Harbaugh is the first person to admit he's obsessed with football. Everything else is secondary. This is a man who traveled to Paris with his wife, went to a Mexican restaurant that appears to be decent but by no means world-renowned, and declared it the best restaurant while also boiling down his personality into a damn near perfect tweet.

Harbaugh is a blunt instrument. He doesn't get sick. He doesn't take holidays. He's a jackhammer. We know this.

Harbaugh also has strong ties to the military. One of his oldest, closest friends is retired Marine colonel Jim Minick, who now serves at Michigan's director of football operations. He has a well-documented history of bringing in military officers to speak to his teams. He stops by Omaha Beach while on vacation. He welcomes servicemen into his office and genuinely looks more excited to take a photo with them than vice versa.

Which brings us to yesterday. Harbaugh emerged from the fall camp submarine—his term; he's also referred to it as a "bunker"—to address the media for the first game-week press conference of the season. Harbaugh is well-known for his unpredictable, off-the-cuff answers in pressers (not to mention on Twitter). We have a "jim harbaugh says things he probably shouldn't" tag, and the proprietor of this site has described him as "being himself at maximum volume at all times" on multiple occasions.

The odds that Harbaugh had the time or inclination to seriously ponder Colin Kaepernick's protest of the national anthem before the press conference are exceedingly low. This is a football coach known for being way more football-obsessed than even the average football-obsessed football coach. He's briefly emerging from three weeks of fall camp and its four-hour practices and endless film study to talk about the Hawaii game. He's probably aware of the basic details of Kaepernick's protest, but that's not anywhere close to his primary focus. He's thinking about his team, preparing for Hawaii, and not letting on anything about the ongoing quarterback competition.

[Hit THE JUMP.]

Fifteen minutes into a twenty-minute presser, Harbaugh is asked about Kaepernick. This is how our press conference correspondent, Adam Schnepp, transcribed the exchange:

As someone who knows Colin Kaepernick, what do you think about his stance to sit during the Anthem, and do you think it will cost him his job with the 49ers?

“I acknowledge his right to do that, but…I don’t respect the…the motivation or the…or the action.”

He pauses three times in that one sentence, which stands in stark contrast to the rest of the presser. The video shows a man who is searching for the right words and isn't quite sure he found them:

Harbaugh went off-the-cuff, which is his nature. He didn't choose his words carefully.

Colin Kaepernick, on the other hand, has spent a great deal of time thinking about his motivation and his action. After the media picked up on his protest, he spent 18 minutes discussing in detail why he won't stand for the national anthem. Before that, he addressed the 49ers in a players-only meeting, one that teammates described as both "productive and informative." At least one player whose initial reaction mirrored Harbaugh's emerged from the meeting with a different mindset:

“To be honest with you, I took offense to it,” 49ers center Daniel Kilgore said upon learning Kaepernick opted not to stand for the Star-Spangled Banner out of protest for what he sees as injustice for minorities in the United States.

“But after Kap stating his case today, and seeing where he was coming from, I do stand with Kap when he says, ‘Enough is enough against crime and the violence, discrimination and racism.’

“I believe enough is enough. I can see where people would think it’s bad with the national anthem and the military. For me, I’m going to stand there every time. I’m going to think about and honor those who are fighting and those who have fought, my family members, my friends. If Kap decides not to, that’s his decision.”

While Kilgore may not be joining Kaepernick in protest, he acknowledges and understands the impetus behind it, and that is a critical distinction.

Harbaugh, unlike Kilgore, didn't talk to Kaepernick this week. My assumption, based on Harbaugh's reaction and that of many others, as well as his background, is that he viewed Kaepernick's protest as a disrespectful act to the military, to which the flag and the anthem are inextricably linked; just look at Michigan's upcoming military appreciation festivities for the UCF game, which will feature "two large American field flags [that] will be held by over 150 veterans and service members" during the anthem among several other military tributes. I doubt he'd considered Kaepernick's pointed views on police violence, not to mention his direct experience with it:

-Q: Have you ever been pulled over unjustly or had a bad experience in that regard?

-KAEPERNICK: Yes. Multiple times.

I mean, I’ve had times where one of my roommates was moving out of a house in college and because we were the only black people in that neighborhood, the cops got called and all of us had guns drawn on us. I mean, came in the house without knocking, guns drawn, on one of my teammates and roommates.

So I have experienced this. People close to me have experienced this. This isn’t something that’s a one-off case here, a one-off case there.

When Harbaugh initially said he didn't respect Kaepernick's "motivation," he unwittingly invalidated the very real issues that Kaepernick is addressing with his act of protest. It was one of the worst possible word choices.  Immediately after the press conference ended, he corrected that error:

If Harbaugh had said that initially, he wouldn't be in the midst of a media firestorm, or at least not one that's nearly this heated. While he still takes exception to Kaepernick's action, that's a position that doesn't invalidate years, decades, centuries of America's history, as well as the present state of relations between police and minorities in many parts of this country.

You may still disagree with Harbaugh. Kaepernick's protest is nonviolent, even nonintrusive—he sat for the anthem in the first preseason game, too, and nobody noticed—and when the media picked up on it, it sparked a nation-wide conversation that's led to some remarkable revelations. I majored in history; without Kaepernick's protest, I wouldn't be aware of the third verse of the Star Spangled Banner. That appears to be the case with one of Harbaugh's star players, Jourdan Lewis, as well. If the goal of protest—a deeply American act dating back to the very genesis of this country—is to raise awareness of issues and drive change, Kaepernick hit the mark; again, look at the reaction from his teammates after the players-only meeting.

You may still disagree with Kaepernick, too. The national anthem and the flag are symbols that, for many of us, stand for freedom, equality, and the sacrifices so many have made to uphold those values. Kaepernick's freedom of expression extends to his critics, and they have a valid point, too: many, many people have died fighting for the country and values that flag symbolizes, and Kaepernick's actions can be interpreted as disrespect of that country and those values in that context. I can't know for sure, but it's quite possible Harbaugh feels that way.

This is all well and good as long as there's an acknowledgment that this discussion has valid opinions on both sides. Harbaugh's initial statement didn't leave room for that. His clarification did.

In an ideal world, Harbaugh would've been prepared to address the issue—the question wasn't hard to see coming—and better express his true feelings on the matter, or acknowledge that he wasn't ready to address it and put forth a no comment. His brother, Baltimore Ravens coach John Harbaugh, had thought through his answer enough to quote Voltaire when asked about Kaepernick:

"Voltaire so eloquently stated, 'I may not agree with what you say, but I'll defend it until death your right to say it,'" John Harbaugh said. "That's a principle that our country is founded on. I don't think you cannot deny someone the right to speak out or mock or make fun or belittle anybody else's opinion."

Jim Harbaugh, however, is a blunt instrument. He answered the question. By his own admission, he missed the mark.

I hate when people tell sports figures to stick to sports. These are people with experiences and opinions that are often quite valuable, and they have a larger platform than most. Context matters, though. Jim Harbaugh is not a food critic. He is not a politician. He is not a social commentator. He is a football coach. We shouldn't be surprised that he sounded like one when asked to address a complicated, nuanced, and controversial social issue in between questions about the depth chart and this season's schedule.

Comments

OysterMonkey

August 30th, 2016 at 10:54 PM ^

I respect your decision to serve, but I feel like this is just contentless bluster: "I'm offended because I feel like the flag and national anthem symbolize what I fought for. They symbolize what some of my brothers and sisters in arms died for." What did you fight for if not the freedom to stand up for what you believe?

Beat 'Em

August 31st, 2016 at 1:29 AM ^

I did fight to protect individual freedoms and liberties, and I recognized his right to express himself in that manner. You just can't expect me to support someone who chooses to use those freedoms to disrespect the flag that means a great deal to me. In between deployments, I served as the OIC on a funeral detail at Fort Hood for a month. As I presented the flag to grieving widows or mothers, I asked them to accept it "as a token of appreciation for your loved one's honorable and faithful service." That's what it means to me. If you really can't understand why it would bother me to see someone refuse to stand for that same flag, even though I willingly chose to fight for the right to do just that, I really don't know what else I can say to you.

OysterMonkey

August 31st, 2016 at 7:55 AM ^

Sorry about the dickishness of my other comment and thanks for engaging me anyway. I do actually want to understand your perspective-as you can probably gather I wasn't in the military. I'm also not a very patriotic person, which probably makes me doubly dense here.

Why I'm confused by some of the response of vets I've seen is that Kaepernick isn't protesting the military-to him the flag means something different than it does to you. You fought for the good stuff about America, he's protesting the shitty stuff. I guess my perspective is that the flag symbolizes all of it-good and bad-and can appropriately be the subject of honor and protest, just like America can appropriately be the subject of praise and blame.

Beat 'Em

August 31st, 2016 at 10:18 AM ^

I agree that the flag means different things to different people, and that's ok. I don't want to take away his right to protest in that manner. He says that he isn't protesting the military, yet some veterans are still offended. Some white southerners say that they don't mean to offend African Americans with the confederate flag, yet they (understandably) still do. I just wish he would choose to express his thoughts using a different method. Not because he has to, but because he realizes that his actions are having unintended consequences and he has enough respect and common courtesy not to offend a group of veterans. I completely understand where you are coming from in believing that the flag can be used both to honor and protest. I respect that. I even agree with it. I'm simply saying that if you shared in some of the same experiences that I have, you might also hope that people would choose a different way to express their beliefs.

pescadero

August 31st, 2016 at 4:06 PM ^

"You just can't expect me to support someone who chooses to use those freedoms to disrespect the flag that means a great deal to me."

In talking with several military friends (former A-10 pilot, former M1A1 tank commander and driver of FAC Humvee in Iraq, Marine munitions loader VMA(AW)-224 in Iraq) they say that the very idea of someone standing in contradiction to their beliefs is disrespecting the flag.

 

 

pescadero

August 31st, 2016 at 4:01 PM ^

"I'm offended because I feel like the flag and national anthem symbolize what I fought for."

They symbolize EVERYTHING about our nation, good and bad.

 

It represents defeating Fascism in WW2 and it represents massacres of Native Americans in the late 1800s.

It represents the moon landing and it represents the Tuskegee Experiments.

It represents the freedom to sit through the national anthem and it represents interring ethnic Japanese US citizens unConstitutionally.

It represents digging the Panama canal, and the banana republic-esque false revolution we fomented to create the country of Panama.

 

Etc., Etc.

 

The Oracle

August 30th, 2016 at 5:28 PM ^

This sounds like it was written by someone who desperately wants to believe that Harbaugh thinks the way he does. My money is on the idea that Harbaugh is very pro-police, and not at all on board with Kaepernick's views. At the same time, many of his players probably feel quite differently, so he has to choose his words carefully. I love mgoblog, but it seems a bit hypocritical to preclude the political speech of others while promoting your own political point of view.

Rabbit21

August 30th, 2016 at 6:29 PM ^

In that case yes, it was. But the movement itself is born of a deep and justified frustration with how the police interacts with African Americans and there has to be a way to make that better. From Air Force pilots to Engineers to Entrepeneurs, every single African American friend I have has had negative encounters with the police when they were doing nothing that should have aroused suspicion. Studies may show that, statistically, an encounter with police is not more likely for an African American male to be shot, but they also show they are far more likely to result in rough treatment, that's a problem. There are issues with the tone of the BLM movement and its expansion into every single Social cause ever, but pretending this isn't real is dumb. I, am, in general, a law and order guy, but there is obviously something worthy of reform here and a good faith discussion is needed.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

The Oracle

August 30th, 2016 at 6:47 PM ^

Perception isn't reality. I've been a cop for 24 years and I'm white. On many occasions, I've stopped cars at night and encountered irate drivers absolutely convinced that they were stopped because of their race. Drive up behind a car at night and try to see if you can determine who is driving. Each time it happened, I would calmly explain the reason for the the stop and that I had no idea who was in the car. I would offer the person the opportunity to walk back to my car and take a look from my perspective. No one was interested, because they KNEW why the had been stopped. They were also wrong.

Wolverrrrrrroudy

August 31st, 2016 at 9:28 AM ^

Naturally and even worse is that these kind of stunts by BLM and KAP feed the perception and create a vicious circle.  I'm assuming you are also a human being and your natural reaction to someone you approach at the window who is respectful is also very different than when you encounter someone irate and disrepectful to you for doing your job.

cletus318

August 30th, 2016 at 6:55 PM ^

Yes, but the second DOJ report also highlighted a multitude of abuses by the Ferguson police department that disproportionately affected blacks and other racial minorities. Similar findings were revealed in reports on Baltimore, Cleveland, Chicago, New Orleans, New York City, Maricopa County, Arizona, and on and on. Regardless of how one feels about Kaepernick's protest, those are real issues affecting real people.

SalvatoreQuattro

August 30th, 2016 at 5:46 PM ^

country.It is populated by easy to offend blowhards who are more interested in ranting and raving than actually having a frank and respectful discussion. Yes,there is racism in this country. There also is sexism, homophobia, misogyny and misandry, Islamophobia, anti-Catholicism, and a plethora of politics-based hatreds. Our melting pot is filled with a bitter stew of animosity created out of historical and contemporary sins. We are not an unified people. We truthfully have never been. The concept of whiteness, as false as it is in real terms, was supposed to surmount the conflicting beliefs and experiences of the European immigrants by creating a common culture. Unfortunately, it was done so on the backs of the African and the Native. The legacy is the carving out in the heart of America a reservoir of anger and acrimony that has fueled in part Kaepnerick's protest and the reaction to it. America is looking more and more like Yugoslavia or Austria-Hungary. I fear that Balkanization is a very real danger if things do not improve.

Rabbit21

August 30th, 2016 at 6:19 PM ^

Then, and I say this with all due respect. If you have no inclination to help make it better and rather simply comment on how awful it is, I would invite you to live somewhere else.

Good luck finding somewhere that doesn't have the things you speak of.

The USA has always tried to create a nation out of a mass of varying tribal groups, this was always going to have tension and resentment. We can either continue to try to live up to the ideals of the founding and realize it's an imperfect experiment but continue to try to be better and make progress to being a unified country of various tribal groups, or we can feed ourselves this poison of how an imperfect history means the whole experiment is unworthy and contemptuous and go down the Balkanization path. I honestly don't know which way it's going to go, but I do know this, Kaepernick has a perfect right to do what he did, just as anyone else has the right to say it's a desperate, jackassed move of a guy who's not a good quarterback anymore who wants to stay in the spotlight.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

arhopp

September 1st, 2016 at 12:32 PM ^

Well said Rabbit. I find it ridiculous that Ace felt he had to write an entire piece to explain why Harbaugh (and the majority of Americans btw) are offended when someone like Kaepernick takes a dump on the country. Is national pride such a foreign concept these days that you have to write an apology piece explaining why it's reasonable to criticize someone for turning their back on the flag? It's almost like you're not allowed to love the country unless you veil your pride in support of the military.

OysterMonkey

August 30th, 2016 at 5:28 PM ^

There were one quadrillion nations in the Universe, but the nation Dwayne Hoover and Kilgore Trout belonged to was the only one with a national anthem which was gibberish sprinkled with question marks.

doggdetroit

August 30th, 2016 at 5:54 PM ^

Excellent post Ace. To those who are mad that Ace had the audacity to bring this up:

A) this is Brian's blog

B) Ace is Brian's #2 man

Put A and B together and they can write about whatever they want. Further, as the collective face of mgoblog, I think they owed everyone a response to Harbaugh's comments, and Ace's response is 100% on point. I would rather see Ace or Brian acknowledge the story and give their opinion on it as opposed to them burying their heads in the sand and pretending nothing happened.

The Reeve

August 30th, 2016 at 6:34 PM ^

Of course they can serve orange soda at their soda stand. But they've been serving root beer, which I like. I hate freaking orange soda. If they don't take it off the menu, they I will go to another pop stand, no matter how good their root beer was.

The Reeve

August 30th, 2016 at 6:57 PM ^

And here I thought I was indispensable.


The point is that freedom goes both ways and that mgoblog thrives in large part because they do not bluster about politics or permit the readership to do so. If mgoblog wants to be political (orange soda), I guarantee this blog will wither in direct proportion to their politicking. That is the market, and they best pay attention to the customer.

CompleteLunacy

August 30th, 2016 at 7:17 PM ^

Nothing upsets me more than this attitude about the blog. It's just...that's the best response to critics who genuinely like it here but disagree with some stuff? "Just go, it's not your blog"? Isn't that the same sort of attitude that we all lambasted Dave Brandon for? Wouldn't it be a bit hypocritical to shame DB for emailing "go find another team" and then tell people who criticize a post here to "go find a new blog"

Yeah yeah I know...I'll just show myself out now.

Ginuvas

August 30th, 2016 at 7:56 PM ^

While there might seem like a parallel between "go find another team" and go find another blog, it seems like a bit of a stretch to compare something that many people here have probably spent tens (or hundreds) of thousands of dollars on and a blog.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad