Barry Every of Rivals just released his final rankings of the Elite 11 and Devin Gardner was ranked number 1. It's behind a paywall so I won't write everything but he says that Gardner will eventually have the ability to take over a game like Jason Campbell, Vince Young and Pryor.
Other rankings of note: #3 Robert Bolden, #12 Joe Boisture
Awesome
Jason Campbell?
How does Jason Campbell compare to Gardner in anything but skin tone? he's a pocket passer
I thought the same thing. It
I thought the same thing. It seemed like Every was comparing a lot of guys to Jason Campbell this week. I wouldn't look that much into it. He's probably just on a Jason Campbell trip.
And rivals still hasnt given
And rivals still hasnt given him his 5th star. He deserves to be ranked alot higher than 171
The Charles Woodson Show
Every said he definitely
Every said he definitely belongs in the Top 100. Rivals put out their new rankings before this event, so by the time the next update rolls around, expect DG to be well within the top 100. Don't know about a 5th star, since Every says he hopes DG will redshirt, but definitely in the Top 100.
I am wondering how Pryor comes in to
the conversation when taking over a game is the topic. Up to this point he has not demonstrated that ability at the college level. Unless they are comparing him to Pryor in HS I think that is a strange assertion.
I think he's probably
I think he's probably referencing the ABILITY to take over the game, be it with an accurate arm or agile legs. "The best athlete on the field" kind of takeover.
well once again, I have not
well once again, I have not seen pryor exhibit that ability in his first year of college football... I think it's a bit unreasonable to bring him up in the conversation of "taking over a game" when the guy hasn't actually ever, you know, "taken over a game".
You also haven't seen Gardner
You also haven't seen Gardner exhibit that ability at the college level. Comparing Gardner to Pryor physically or athletically makes sense to me. Saying someone has that physical ability is one thing. Saying they will do it is another matter entirely. Pryor has the physical tools and talent available to take over a game. This is what scouts are referring to when they say Gardner resembles Pryor.
If no one ever heard of Pryor before the last season
I still believe he would be hyped IMO. Guys saying he's over-rated sound dangerously like homers to me. The kid was a true freshman and as such, played quite well. I also think it's pretty obvious that he has a high level of talent, and the Vince Young comparisons are not far-fetched in any way. If he can progress strongly as a passer, as Young did (who was terrible passing his freshman year) he will be freaking dangerous.
"Everyone gets dumped Gabe. Let me give you some advice: a little coverup on your Adams Apple will make it appear smaller. Which will make you appear less like a transvestite."
Pryor proved he can take over
Pryor proved he can take over a game ... or at least lead a game winning drive on the road (Wisconsin). He just hasn't proven he can do it consistently ... or even throw the ball straight consistently. I think he meant he has the ability to take over a game or maybe has the same freakish athleticism.
There is little I can stand less at the moment than when OSUsters talk about how great TP is, when he hasnt proven shit. He has a lot of athletic ability. They have to be going off of the hype machine and the HS #1 rating he got to think he's that great but yet when you say, as a wolverine said on bucknuts, that Gardner is better than Taylor Graham they say "How do you figure that he is better? Graham is light years ahead of Gardner in passing ability."
Oh-oh oh-oh oh-oh Here comes the ban hammer.
Mix of Campbell and Young
Oh great, we'll have a mental disaster that's on the slow end of the mobile qb spectrum.
Err, maybe that's not what he meant.
MIIIIIIIIICH
What?
How can Boisture be ranked 12th at the Elite 11 camp? It is one thing to be ranked last, but to be ranked 12th out of a possible 11 guys is not good.
If there were 12 kids
If there were 12 kids there... Kinda like how you can be ranked 11th in the Big Ten.
Elite 11 = 12 QBs
Elite 11 always takes 12 kids - kinda like a "baker's dozen," if you will.
Jokenjin
I'm pretty sure that the elite 11 is misnamed
Like the Big 10 having 11 teams the Elite 11 has 12 Qb's (correct me other gurus if I'm wrong)
"A house divided against itself cannot stand"
Thanks
I was hoping it was just that Elite 11 realized Boisture didn't belong and ended up giving him a real slap in the face and ranked him 12th. With that being said, if we were under the previous administration, he would be a nice pick up to have to come in after Mallett/Threet.
If they were to release a new
If they were to release a new set of rankings on positive attitude, I think it's safe to say Boisture would be competing for first place.
Way to go Gardner! Keep it
Way to go Gardner! Keep it up.
Class of '02 and still "All In".
One Thing for Campbell
I will say one thing for Campbell, though - he has handled the qb debacle in Washington with class and dignity, something Cutler cannot claim. When the Redskins went after Cutler and then Sanchez, Campbell remained loyal to the team and showed up at offseason workouts all the time. When his teammates asked him why he was still showing up, he said that he's still the quarterback of the team and until someone tells him different, he's going to continue to work hard and not let his teammates down. If Gardner's character is like that, then I am damn glad to have him compared to Jason Campbell.
Also something to note - when he was in college, he had a different offensive coordinator every year and he still put out decent numbers and even led Auburn to an undefeated season. Again, I would be very, VERY happy if Garnder does this for us as well.
Either way - I'm damn excited for this kid.
Jokenjin
Great to hear!
And as far as
Great to hear!
And as far as the star rankings go, we've gotta remember that no matter whether he's ranked in the top 50 or top 200, he's a 5 star in Michigan's system. He's a perfect fit for what Rodriguez wants to do and I look forward to great things out of him in the future.
With all the love that
With all the love that Gardner is getting, do we think he might pas Brunetti as the #1 dual-threat QB in the 2010 class. I know the rankings don't matter, but #1 is still #1.
Tell me you all weren't pumped when you found out Turner was the best player in Ohio...
agreed
It's not everything, but I would love to see him move up the rankings as #1 dual-threat QB
BlueDrew
I wasn't pumped when I found
I wasn't pumped when I found out Turner was the best player in Ohio.
Ok, I actually was, I'm just saying what you told me to say.
Log Jam - Great problem to have.
Sounds like we might have 3 good QB's fighting for playing time after 2010. Tate showed his stuff in the Spring Game. Denard has "really nice zing on the ball - that, coupled with his athleticism, should make him pretty scary." Now DG blows up the Elite 11 camp. After having zero quality QBs in 2008, this will be a welcome change. Now I'm really fired up for the future of UM football.
with all this talk about how
with all this talk about how good gardner is wouldnt it be awesome if he overtook the overall number one spot in the country
The Charles Woodson Show
lol
lets not go too far romo
i was just saying cuz
i was just saying cuz everyone is talking about how good he is. i read somewhere that he is looking like pryor on the field. hey pryor was the number one recruit in the country so it was just a suggestion.
The Charles Woodson Show
It would be awesome, but it
It would be awesome, but it would also be awesome if my Ford Contour turned into the new Mustang.
This is great. I knew DG was
This is great. I knew DG was a good player, but after following his recruitment and camp appearances, count me in as being very excited to see him on campus.
That being said, I hope he redshirts a year to work on learning the entire offense and his mechanics. This kid could be very dangerous under center for us. I hope he turns into an Armenti Edwards/Dennis Dixon/Juice Williams type player (I'm sick of the Vince Young comparisions so I figured I'd offer something different).
I'm liking the Dennis Dixon
I'm liking the Dennis Dixon comparison.
Tall, fast, big arm, more lengthy than stocky, around same body size
Only problem with Dennis Dixon
comparison is that Dixon only had one good year at Oregon - his senior yr. Dixon was the starting QB his junior year and halfway through the year got demoted to second string.
This is good to hear
but every time I see him throw with his weird side-arm mechanics is brings back memories of Navarre pegging O-linemen in the back of the head. I hope he is really able to finesse his throwing abilities this season.
I know I have seen this posted here before, but event though he is 'committed,' DG cannot work out with any trainers until he officially arrives on campus, right?
I have a Fandom Endurance III merit badge
I'm assuming you mean
I'm assuming you mean Michigan trainers not just trainers in general. I don't think he would be able to work out with them but I can guarantee that he at least can get his hands on the workout or some sort of beginners course to the workouts to get a head start. I'd be mildly surprised if all the recruits didn't actually.
Oh-oh oh-oh oh-oh Here comes the ban hammer.
so looking past the DG
so looking past the DG praise, does this mean boisture might be taking a fall in the rankings sometime? i mean i know he was the 12th best out of 12 great QBs but isn't he supposed to be a top 5 pocket passer who's at a camp that seems to cater to pocket passers? seems to not bode well for his ranking
Boisture lol. State owns
Boisture lol. State owns in-state recruiting.
Another good piece of evidence
that he's a pretty damn fine QB. Say, I just started following recruiting when RR got hired. When's the last time we had an Elite 11 QB? What's our history there.
Follow me on Twitter @gfraley05
Let's hope we can find some way to effectively use Gardner and Forcier together.