Exoneration, Probation, Over Comment Count

Brian

jihad-2006-2007-tercera-guerra-mundial-01lg barwis
It's been real, jihad guy and generic Barwis picture.

When this was breaking last night I was trudging through the fourth quarter of the Penn State game, gin in hand, and didn't feel like rushing to do anything except maybe to throw up. But it happened and it's over and the news is good, and by good we mean "exactly what everyone expected" but at least all those wild theories about how the NCAA is going to blow up the program and make an example out of Rodriguez are gone:

The NCAA has concluded that Michigan coach Rich Rodriguez did not fail to promote an atmosphere of compliance, a previous allegation that the school challenged, a source close to the situation said Wednesday night.

Other reports state that the NCAA has accepted the self imposed penalties and added a third year of probation. The official release will happen at 3 PM, but Michigan's leaking all the relevant details early. If you'll allow me a moment of self-congratulation, that's exactly what was projected around these parts when Michigan announced its response to the notice of allegations.

Our long and winding journey that started with wildly overheated allegations and ends with some misinterpreted stretching and excessively involved grad assistant ends. After this afternoon's flurry of redundancy there are no more news events to push this to the forefront, so Michigan can get on with the reductions quietly and the proverbial dark cloud hanging over the program can finally evaporate.

I can't emphasize enough how much of a steaming crock of crap the initial Free Press story was and how richly everyone involved with it deserves to be fired, but at least they immolated the idea that journalistic ethics are a reason to read boring neutral "objective" copy and stupid 600-word columns dashed off without an ounce of research. They also drove a ton of traffic here as Michigan fans looked for accurate projections of what was going to happen, and in doing so obliterated the idea that bias, which this place has in spades, necessarily leads to inaccuracy. So thanks for that. Send me your resumes in five years when you all lose your jobs; I'll get back to you with all possible speed.

Comments

Magnum P.I.

November 4th, 2010 at 7:23 PM ^

I'm not talking about investigating them. I'm talking about taking every opportunity in public discourse to make it known that the Freep has compromised ethics and, worse, decided to make their number-one project of 2009 a misleading report to cause a large proportion of already-burdened-and-recessed Michiganders to feel like shit for a calendar year.

bouje

November 4th, 2010 at 11:51 AM ^

If the Freep guys had just held onto the story and michigan self reports violations... What do we get? Some secondary violations? Maybe a major violation.
<br>
<br>The whole ordeal is and will always be bs and everyone at the Freep should be ashamed.

This is Michigan

November 4th, 2010 at 12:25 PM ^

Michigan would have never self-reported the violations. It was part of UM's stance in this whole ordeal that they "misinturpretted the rules". Without the initial reports from the Freep, UM would have carried on their "normal" activities, doing things which they thought they were doing the right way.  

03 Blue 07

November 4th, 2010 at 2:45 PM ^

You're going to need to link to something to support your assertion that Michigan's stance was "misinterpretation."  They didn't have time to self-report once they became aware that they were possibly committing infractions. And if they had the time, I bet they would have. For example, OSU self-reports violations all the time; it's good policy, frankly.

Plegerize

November 4th, 2010 at 11:54 AM ^

It is relieving to know that we can finally move on and just play.

Thank you Brian for all that you have done. It is so unfortunate that your opinion goes mostly unnoticed with the MSM but know that without someone like you, it would be very tough to survive as a Michigan fan.

Schmoe

November 4th, 2010 at 12:01 PM ^

Thank you Brian and MGoStaff.  I have appreciated your thorough reporting on this issue from day one.  It has been very enlightening.  Go MGoBlog!

MechEng97

November 4th, 2010 at 12:14 PM ^

Yes this was spot on what was projected here on this site.  Your post is also dead-on why I read this site daily.  I don't need to hear "unbiased" commentary from people with possible agendas..I AM a fan and want to hear about Michigan related content with a fans perspective/bias.  That is the point. 

The fact that this site goes to great lengths to determine facts is what makes the combination so effective.   I don't need anything else and the smug Beat Writers can...well....kiss your @ss :)

Let's hope this news starts some good things around here...It's been hard to take and Floyd's injury is just piling on...

 

bronxblue

November 4th, 2010 at 12:31 PM ^

Quick and efficient response by Brian, and one I welcome.  The reality of the situation never meshed with what the Freep wanted it to be, so they fabricated and exaggerated minor issues in the hope of driving traffic.  Of course, the end result was an erosion of their credibility and the sense amongst neutral readers that guys like Rosenberg and Snyder cannot be trusted wholly.  

Also, if you don't want to see a prime example of delusion, I would advise highly against visiting the Freep site right now.  Let's just say that the ASPCA might need to step in for the equine that is currently being pummeled well beyond its expiration on the front page.

Seth

November 4th, 2010 at 12:32 PM ^

I find no happiness in this whole affair, except that I am now associated with the blog who got it right.

The board, be careful not to interpret:

and in doing so obliterated the idea that bias, which this place has in spades, necessarily leads to inaccuracy.

As:

and in doing so proved the idea that bias, which this place has in spades, leads to accuracy.

Bias has its place in journalism, mostly in providing a journalist incentive to fisk something that is factually inaccurate. If bias fueled this blog to find the objective truth, it was because extreme bias led Rosenberg and Snyder to trample objective truth while simultaneously, hypocritically cloaking themselves in it.

What matters most to me is accuracy, not having the right bias. The Freep destroyed its credibility by letting a journalists with an extreme bias use the good name of the paper to fling shit at Michigan's coach just to see what could stick. MGoBlog increased its credibility by assessing and scrutinizing the available evidence, and basing a cogent and reasonable prediction solely on that. It is that which we are celebrating, not that it was accomplished despite Brian's (and our) biases.

aawolve

November 4th, 2010 at 12:42 PM ^

It was nice to know what was actually going on, rather than being just another ignoramus, and to be able to explain the reality of the situation to my less informed friends. This blog really helped bring some sanity to the situation.

mGrowOld

November 4th, 2010 at 12:49 PM ^

Five years?   No freaking way does the Freep survive five years as a print publication with their existing staff.  I put the over/under at two years before they go the way of the AA News first and then slowly slide under the waves of total bankruptcy second.

And it is my fervent prayer that RR is here to wave them all goodbye when they go.

Yard Dog

November 4th, 2010 at 12:54 PM ^

continue to dissipate.  Regardless of what RR has said, these things are a distraction and do affect recruiting, so the quicker they are resolved, the better, especially when the penalty almost exactly mirrors the self-imposed version.  Nothing to see here, move along.

Now about that winning thing...

mgoblue0970

November 4th, 2010 at 1:05 PM ^

Move along nothing to see here.

Since when has the freep ever let the facts get in the way of a good story?  People are outraged/slamming the freep?  Why?  This is exactly what they want.  Their editor obviously thinks sensationalism = ratings. 

Particularly regarding Sharp and Rosenberg, they don't care either.  Sharp has publicly said his readers are idiots and it's his job to keep it real.  That last part are his words.  Have you ever written those two ass clowns?  Got a reply?  And what did the reply say?  Sharp and Rosenberg don't give two shits about what we think about journalistic integrity; their job is to sell papers and generate page hits.  Period.  Again, both of them and their editor have made that crystal clear.

The best way to resolve this situation is to just ignore the freep.  I do now.  Move along nothing to see here.

JMK

November 4th, 2010 at 1:49 PM ^

Agree wholeheartedly that Brian & the MGoCrew deserve credit for their excellent work.  Let's also hear it for the late Compliance blog that helped them out.

WindyCityBlue

November 4th, 2010 at 1:51 PM ^

Every now and again, I go to the link below.  Brightens my day everytime.

Funny thing, I knew Rosenburg at Michigan.  Nice guy, really.

Also, I was at an event where I met a bunch of the Ufer family.  They all are not big fans of RR, but want to kick the shit out of Rosenburg if they see him in public.

 

http://www.amazon.com/War-As-They-Knew-Schembechler/product-reviews/B0031MA900/ref=cm_cr_pr_hist_1?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=0&filterBy=addOneStar

M-Wolverine

November 4th, 2010 at 2:13 PM ^

Well, as long as we're playing a little bit of deserved I-told-you-so, I seem to recall you needed to be convinced by people on the board (as well as compliance guy) that the 3rd year of probation was probably forthcoming too, which wasn't your "accepted as is" stance.

wolverine2003

November 4th, 2010 at 3:46 PM ^

"The committee noted that the violations of daily and weekly countable hours
rules, though serious, were far less extensive than originally reported and that no student athletes were substantially harmed."

Even the NCAA noted the freep was full of it. They were under no obligation to put this in.  I love it.

bluewave720

November 4th, 2010 at 4:20 PM ^

I have not posted anything about the freep for a very long time, but I keep having this sense that I still have something hanging over me right now.  What was it I forgot to do?  Oh yeah, shake my fist at the moon and yell:

Fuck you, you fucking assholes.  I will never read your piece of shit newspaper ever again.  I have told our front office to never purchase your goddamn parasitic rag and I always say something to patients along the lines of "Oh, I stopped reading that paper when it turned into a tabloid" every time I see one with a copy.  You are an abomination of our First Amendment and have turned yourselves into a laughing-stock.  Rosenberg and Sharp, you two are the most impressive personifications of a syphilitic chancre I could have ever imagined seeing.  I know you think you are cleaver, but you have both sold your souls for this and other "stories."  

Clears throat, starts to smile, internally deletes all memories/thoughts/criticisms of the Detroit Free Press.   No need to ever talk or think about that irrelevant media source again.

mgoblue0970

November 4th, 2010 at 6:48 PM ^

As I posted earlier though, the freep doesn't care. 

They are probably laughing their ass off at this thread.  They're sitting there thinking about the 100s of comments this thread will generate and think about all the page clicks going to get sent their way as a result -- there's no such thing as bad publicity right?

The freep is a tabloid.  While the cussing feels good and is therapeutic, it's not going to change the freep's tune one single bit.

mgoblue0970

November 4th, 2010 at 9:26 PM ^

+1... I feel your pain.  :)

I remember when the BOX house put up the banner "Rosenberg punches dolphins".  Sharp was outraged and tried to have the banner torn down.  To hell with the 1st Ammendment... that only applies if you write for a rag.

I still get pissed when I think about that.  But what we need to do is to totally ignore the freep and send them the way of the A2 News.

bluewave720

November 4th, 2010 at 9:49 PM ^

I become demented.  I hope I am "pleasantly demented" as they say.  I really don't want to be that asshole that everyone tries to avoid in the rehab center/nursing home/hospital.  

However, I can be absolutely certain, than when my life starts playing in front of me like a rudimentary computer program, I will utter one phrase:

"Rosenberg punches dolphins."

That is one of the single greatest statements I have ever heard or read. 

saveferris

November 4th, 2010 at 5:41 PM ^

As much as I want to tell Rosenburg to eat a back of dicks, I think it's good to follow Brian's example by taking the high road, except that I really want Mike Rosenburg to eat a bag of dicks....

myblueheaven

November 4th, 2010 at 6:24 PM ^

Won't the recruiters from rival schools warn potential big time recruits that Rich Rod still may not be at Michigan if he's found guilty of any wrong doing there! I would think so but it probably wouldn't work as much now that he has been found innocent in the Michigan incident, who knows? I'm just happy that this part is over and Freep can suck a big fat cock that just went anal, fuckers.... Go Blue!!!