I am 30, so 1984 is about the beginning of me actually seeing these guys live.
That being said, this is a pretty weak number. I literally have only heard of 5 of these guys, and one of them (Woods) primarily wore a different number. I always thought Petruziello was pretty solid, though uninspiring. Harrison certainly had a ton of potential, but probably has too much infamy to get my vote.
So I go for Carr. A solid space filler who would have been better off to never have gotten involved in the rushing game.