On Banning Satellite Camps Comment Count

Brian

23354825846_5e028e8fb7_z

[Eric Upchurch]

The NCAA has banned satellite camps, because… [404 reason not found]. But it's done:

I have literally not seen a single peep in favor of this ruling anywhere public, from coaches to athletes to media members. A couple of reporters covering the SEC have related the private thoughts of coaches happy they can binge-watch Everybody Loves Raymond again, but ain't nobody coming out and waving the flag in favor of a rule change that literally only benefits people making 300k+.

This isn't going to have a major impact on Michigan, but it rankles because it is so transparently opposite the NCAA's claimed mission. If there's anyone who takes the NCAA's increasingly hilarious self-promotion seriously anymore, this should end that. It's a cartel of self-interested asshats operating under a veneer of virtue, because you can do astounding things as long as you have said veneer.

Meanwhile Jim Delany sits in a corner burbling about cable subscribers and counting his millions of dollars. What a country.

Additional thoughts will be introduced with an innovative bolded in-line title.

Q: SMSB? Over the past ten years, Sound Mind Sound Body has become a very large camp indeed, one featuring dozens of college coaches and four digits worth of athletes. Either the NCAA just bombed that camp hard or maybe there's a loophole. That loophole could be SMSB's charity nature. Coaches have been allowed there because they volunteer their time, IIRC, and the word choice in the ruling is specific:

If SMSB happens as planned then this is a non-ruling easily evaded. Michigan coaches can just go volunteer at the various SMSB-alikes that will proliferate like mushrooms after a rain.

If college coaches disappear then it's game over.

Ugh, work. This is simultaneously frustrating and very good for Michigan:

Harbaugh is still working harder than your coach. Your coaches who are making six- and seven-figure salaries on the backs of unpaid labor. They are going to sit in a circle and go "LOL remember that time we stopped Harbaugh from working" as Harbaugh invents new ways to torture his enemies.

Hooray lawsuits! This is now very relevant. Jack Swarbrick, ND AD and law-talking guy, on the legal defensibility of the ban:

“The NCAA does not have a very good track record of limiting, without losing an antitrust lawsuit, economic opportunities for coaches,” Swarbrick said Tuesday at the College Football Playoff meetings. “So they should be treading very lightly. The perception is these are school opportunities. A lot of these are coach opportunities purely. Imagine a rule that said, as was introduced years ago, coaches couldn't do national televised advertising because it created a recruiting advantage. … I wouldn't want to defend those lawsuits.”

A 1999 lawsuit resulting from an NCAA rule that limited assistant coach salaries to 16k a year(!) was victorious, leading to the free-for-all you see today. It'll be tough to win that lawsuit if it does come. So we've got that going for us when this hypothetical trial wraps up a decade from now.

[HT: Carl Paulus]

This is not a surgical strike. Via Steve Wiltfong, non-Power 5 coaches are of course upset:

The new ruling basically says mid-major programs aren't allowed to participate in camps not held on campus. For instance, MAC schools flock to Big Ten camps as say an Ohio State camp generally only has a handful of kids good enough to play for the Buckeyes but several that could play for Ball State, Kent State, Toledo or Western Michigan.

Two MAC coaches told 247Sports they weren't sure how this rule affects them. One said "shocking."

Given that I wonder how the hell this legislation even passed. All Group of Five schools should be against it. The Big Ten should be against it. Big chunks of the Big 12, Pac 12, and ACC should be against it. Not only is it transparently against the interests of athletes, it's transparently against the interests of most of D-I.

Good lord, Harbaugh. Perhaps the greatest tragedy in all of this is that we didn't have to clone Sam Webb and almost kill both of 'em:

247Sports is told Michigan had 30 camps lined up, they were going to split groups and sometimes do two a day. Stops would have included North Florida, South Florida, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Orange County, Alabama, South Carolina, Virginia, New Jersey, Mississippi, Tennessee, Ohio, Maryland and Connecticut.

Jim Harbaugh is always himself at maximum volume. Gonna be some fun times in the near future, satellite camps or no.

Comments

turd ferguson

April 8th, 2016 at 4:08 PM ^

I'm fuming about this, but in some ways it helps Michigan.  At this point there's basically a war between Michigan football and the SEC.  That elevates us (and it's fucking awesome).  This kind of thing makes Michigan look like the good guys in a battle against evil, and there are some recruiting benefits from this type of attention.

Rickett88

April 8th, 2016 at 2:16 PM ^

Hard to not love a guy that is working this hard for the team. When the team sees how he spends his free time, how can they not want to play for a guy that's working that hard to make the team better. 

 

WHOS GOT IT BETTER THEN US!?!?!

matty blue

April 8th, 2016 at 2:23 PM ^

i will admit that some of the "he goes up to 11" stuff tends to tire me out, mostly because i can't keep my focus on this stuff 24/7/365...but this shit just makes me want to find a knob that goes to 12.  if our guy is outthinking and outhustling your guy, fuck off.

Bez

April 8th, 2016 at 2:30 PM ^

It's totally insane but I love it.  I laughed out loud when I read 30 camps.

I'm sure Harbaugh knew others were going to follow suit this year, so he's like "cool, I'll do ten times as many!"

BlockM

April 8th, 2016 at 2:18 PM ^

Literally laughing out loud at that list of future camp sites. It must suck so royally bad to have to compete against a guy who would rather work his ass of at *anything* than take a rest day. That jackhammer quote wasn't an exaggeration even in the slightest.

charblue.

April 8th, 2016 at 5:57 PM ^

it rewards laziness. It punishes a coach whose only interest is advancing the game and helping extend its reach thus giving the very organization seeking to ban his method of evangelicalism, a bullshit response to status quo. Well, we've never seen this done before, we can't allow it on a major league level, it might give an unfair advantage.

Here's the unfairness: strength of character, desire and motivation. Not like Harbaugh hasn't been doing this since he stopped playing pro football, which, of course, he has. It's OK training guys at Western Kentucky but not when you are the head coach at Michigan.  In fact, he has never stopped being the game's biggest and perhaps its most active promoter And the problem the NCAA has, has nothing to do with being a problem. It's perception. Why are you doing what no one else does? Why can't you be part of the herd instead of leading it?  Why are you so interested in growing the game and making technigque training and expertise more accesible? It must be to improve your program. Well, yeah. But at the same time, doesn't that benefit everyone?

Fuck the NCAA, which puts no clamps on basketball coaching in any season on any level or in any fucking setting. And it allows the coach at Duke to coach the men's national team and get every opportunity to expand his recruting profile in offseason activiites, lining up McDonald's All-American classes every year based on his Olympic team profile.

The NCAA allows UNC to compete for a national championship in basketball while the program and school is awash in well-documented academic fraud over a score of years.

This hypocritical regulatory body is a creation of the schools who actually give it authority and control because they cannot assume responsibility for their own management and control.

WestQuad

April 8th, 2016 at 2:19 PM ^

So was this basically a few SEC schools with pull getting this passed?   How is this good for anyone other than them?  

Maybe the NCAA should crack down on bagmen instead.

Maybe Harbaugh can have mass sleep-overs where the kids happen to learn about football.  

1145SoFo

April 8th, 2016 at 2:19 PM ^

IMO, the most important point Brian notes is there is not a single, logical defense of the ban (that I have seen, or could possibly imagine).

Just a clear case of the NCAA trying to hand the southern states & other recruiting hotbeds a competitive advantage.

Muttley

April 8th, 2016 at 4:52 PM ^

but not all southerners have SEC ties.

The Detroit car industry lobbied hard for the equivalent in the 80s by placing resctrictions on Japanese auto imports.  I'd say that was slightly more impactful to US consumers.

MichiganExile

April 8th, 2016 at 2:19 PM ^

Brian you are way off on this, there are plenty of people in favor of this ruling. They: a) live in a southern state, b) root for an ACC or SEC team, and c) have a spit can on their desk right this very second. 

Blue N Bama

April 8th, 2016 at 2:26 PM ^

Step 1: Rent aircraft carrier. USS Ann Arbor or my preferred name: USS Go Fuck Yourself

Step 2: Setup campus on said carrier

Step 3: Paint a big maize and blue middle finger on the side of it.

Step 4: Float that MFer off the coast of GA, FL, AL, MS, LA, TX, CA and then run that bitch up the mississippi river during June and July.  Having on campus football camps on deck. 

Step 5: Drop mic

Rabbit21

April 8th, 2016 at 2:49 PM ^

Man Delaney was super-duper on fire today.  Wonder who has pictures of him in a compromising situation?  At this point thats the only possible explanation for this legislative losing streak.

Although frankly, the hockey rule seems to be a bit creepy, who's to say why a guy might delay entering college and why would he need to pay an eligibility price for it, especially when they're still suppossed to be getting an education in the bargain.

Kwitch22

April 8th, 2016 at 2:29 PM ^

Too bad most other coaches are lazy, so they are stopping our coach from doing what he loves doing, coaching football. Is Jack Harbaugh going to go to these camps now? He isn't employed by the school.

BlueinOK

April 8th, 2016 at 2:30 PM ^

This is really going to hurt those kids at the MAC and lower D1 level. Most of the top, top D1 talent will still be discovered, but what about that next level? Great point in here about it hurting MAC schools because they can't go to the larger school camps. This is just bad for everyone not in the SEC and a few ACC schools.